The Gap Between Theory and Practice

Mean-variance optimisation is mathematically rigorous and intellectually compelling. In practice, it has a notorious reputation among professional investors for producing portfolios that are extreme, unstable, and practically unusable. The problem is not with the mathematics — it is with the nature of the inputs the mathematics requires.
To construct an efficient frontier portfolio, the optimiser needs expected returns, variances, and covariances for every asset in the investment universe. For a portfolio of 50 assets, that is 50 expected returns, 50 variances, and 1,225 pairwise covariances. All of these must be estimated from historical data — and all of them are noisy.