Finscape
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Fragility of Optimised Portfolios

Mean-variance optimisation is mathematically rigorous and intellectually compelling. In practice, it has a notorious reputation among professional investors for producing portfolios that are extreme, unstable, and practically unusable. The problem is not with the mathematics — it is with the…

8 cards
Study this deck

Fragility of Optimised Portfolios

In this lesson · 4 sections
Step 2 of 4

The Estimation Error Problem

financial newspaper with stock chart
Photo by Markus Spiske on Unsplash

Expected return estimates are the most treacherous input. Stock returns are highly variable: the standard error of a mean annual return estimated from 20 years of monthly data is large enough that the estimates for most assets are statistically indistinguishable from each other. In other words, we cannot reliably know in advance which assets will have higher expected returns.

The optimiser does not know this. It treats the estimated expected returns as if they were precise and acts on even tiny differences between them. If the estimated expected return for an emerging market bond is 8.1% and for a developed market bond is 7.9%, the optimiser may recommend a 60% allocation to the emerging market bond — a precise, confident response to what is statistical noise.

Richard Michaud described this problem with clarity in his landmark 1989 paper in the Financial Analysts Journal, "The Markowitz Optimization Enigma: Is Optimized Optimal?" Michaud showed that optimisation tends to concentrate the portfolio in the assets with the most estimation error — exactly the assets about which the investor is most uncertain. The "optimal" portfolio is, in effect, an error maximiser.