Finscape
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Fragility of Optimised Portfolios

Mean-variance optimisation is mathematically rigorous and intellectually compelling. In practice, it has a notorious reputation among professional investors for producing portfolios that are extreme, unstable, and practically unusable. The problem is not with the mathematics — it is with the…

8 cards
Study this deck

Fragility of Optimised Portfolios

In this lesson · 4 sections
Step 3 of 4

What Optimised Portfolios Look Like in Practice

graphical user interface, application
Photo by Anne Nygård on Unsplash

Without constraints, a raw mean-variance optimiser typically produces portfolios that would strike any reasonable investor as absurd: 80% in a single small-cap factor, zero allocation to major asset classes, extreme long-short positions. Professional practitioners universally apply ad hoc constraints — no single asset above 10%, no short positions, minimum allocations to major regions — that override the pure optimisation output. The constraints transform the problem into a more plausible portfolio, but they also acknowledge that the unconstrained output was not fit for purpose.

Even with constraints, the optimised portfolio can change dramatically with small changes in inputs. A shift in one expected return estimate of 0.5% may flip the recommended allocation between two asset classes by 30 percentage points. This instability means that regular rebalancing of a mean-variance-optimised portfolio generates high turnover and transaction costs, eroding the theoretical benefits.