Municipal Bonds and Tax-Equivalent Yield

Municipal bonds — bonds issued by state and local governments — pay interest that is exempt from federal income tax and typically from state income tax for residents of the issuing state. This tax exemption means munis carry lower stated yields than comparable taxable bonds; the market prices the exemption into the yield.
For investors in high tax brackets, this exemption makes munis attractive relative to taxable bonds with higher stated yields. The comparison is made using the tax-equivalent yield: muni yield divided by (1 minus the marginal tax rate). For a taxpayer in the 37% bracket, a 3.5% muni yield is equivalent to a taxable yield of 3.5% divided by 0.63, which equals 5.56%. If comparable taxable bonds yield less than 5.56%, the muni is the better after-tax choice.
Below approximately the 22–24% bracket, taxable bonds typically offer better after-tax yields than comparable munis — the exemption's value scales with the taxpayer's rate. A taxpayer in the 12% bracket comparing the same 3.5% muni finds its tax-equivalent yield is only 3.5% divided by 0.88, or 3.98% — a modest advantage that may not compensate for munis' generally lower credit quality and liquidity relative to Treasury bonds.
Investors should also consider the alternative minimum tax (AMT) when evaluating munis. Most municipal bond interest is exempt from the AMT, but bonds issued for certain private-activity purposes — such as airport bonds or bonds for certain housing projects — pay interest that is preference income for AMT purposes. For taxpayers subject to the AMT, private-activity bonds may lose a portion of their tax advantage.