Finscape
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Commodities in a Portfolio

The modern institutional case for commodities as a strategic portfolio allocation was largely built on one paper: "Facts and Fantasies About Commodity Futures" by Gary Gorton (Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania) and K. Geert Rouwenhorst (Yale School of Management), published in 2006 by the…

8 cards
Study this deck

Commodities in a Portfolio

In this lesson · 4 sections
Step 2 of 4

The Post-Publication Challenge

graphical user interface, application
Photo by Anne Nygård on Unsplash

The Gorton-Rouwenhorst paper covers 1959 to 2004. What happened next proved to be a significant complication.

Following the paper's publication and the broader institutionalisation of commodity index investing, large capital flows poured into commodity index products. The value of assets tracking commodity indices grew from tens of billions to hundreds of billions of dollars between 2005 and 2012. Michael Masters, a hedge fund manager, testified before the US Senate in 2008 that this "index speculator" demand was itself a contributor to the 2007-2008 commodity price spike.

More fundamentally, subsequent academic research — most notably Claude Erb and Campbell Harvey's 2013 paper "The Golden Dilemma" and related work — found that the returns from commodity futures over the 2005-2013 period were substantially weaker than the historical record suggested. Commodity futures as a diversified asset class delivered poor nominal returns during a period when equities performed well, and the inflation-hedging properties — while still present in principle — were less consistent in practice.