The Financialisation Problem

The concept of financialisation captures the key mechanism by which the commodity opportunity may have deteriorated. The Gorton-Rouwenhorst paper documented that the positive returns to commodity futures over 1959-2004 came substantially from roll yield in backwardated markets — a return generated because commodity producers structurally needed to hedge (Keynes' normal backwardation theory).
As massive institutional capital entered commodity futures markets post-2005, the structure of commodity markets changed. Large sustained buying of commodity futures pushed near-month contracts up relative to deferred contracts, reducing and in many cases eliminating the backwardation that had historically generated positive roll yield. In energy markets, persistent contango became the norm for extended periods, imposing a negative roll yield on index investors. The structural return source documented by Gorton and Rouwenhorst was partially dissipated by the capital flows that their research had encouraged.
This is a classic example of a strategy that works at small scale (when few investors are pursuing it) but becomes self-defeating when pursued at large scale — a concept related to the limits of arbitrage in financial economics.