The Current Consensus

The contemporary investment consensus on commodities is more measured than the early 2000s enthusiasm suggested:
Inflation hedge: yes, but imperfect. Commodities remain one of the most direct inflation hedges available in a liquid investable form. When inflation is driven by commodity prices — as in 2021-2022 — commodity exposure can provide meaningful protection. However, not all inflation is commodity-driven, and the hedge is imperfect over shorter time horizons.
Return enhancer: probably not, at scale. The equity-like return documented over 1959-2004 has not been reliably replicated in subsequent decades. Current consensus treats commodity allocation as a risk management tool rather than a return source.
Strategic allocation size: 5-10%. Most institutional investors who retain commodity exposure treat it as a modest strategic allocation — large enough to provide meaningful inflation hedging and diversification in stress scenarios, small enough that its underperformance in non-inflationary environments does not materially drag portfolio returns.
Implementation matters enormously. Given the impact of roll yield and financialisation on index returns, how commodity exposure is implemented — which index, which roll methodology, whether through futures or commodity equities — can be as important as the allocation size decision itself.