TCJA Changed Everything
Before the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act took effect in 2018, roughly 30% of American taxpayers itemized their deductions. TCJA made two changes that dramatically shifted this calculation. It roughly doubled the standard deduction, and it capped the SALT deduction at $10,000. The combination meant that many households who had previously itemized — primarily homeowners in high-tax states — no longer had enough deductible expenses to beat the new, higher standard deduction.
By 2024, fewer than 11% of taxpayers itemize. For most Americans, itemizing is no longer worth the effort. Mortgage interest deductibility — once the cornerstone of itemizing for middle-class homeowners — became far less valuable because the higher standard deduction often exceeds whatever itemized deductions a typical household can document.
The taxpayers who still benefit from itemizing tend to share a few characteristics: they own expensive homes with large mortgages, live in high-tax states, make substantial charitable contributions, or have significant out-of-pocket medical expenses. If none of those apply, the standard deduction is almost certainly your better option.