Finscape
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Alpha and Its Limits

In the CAPM framework, alpha is the return an investment earns above what its level of market risk (beta) would predict. If CAPM predicts a portfolio with a given beta should return 8% in a year, and the portfolio actually returns 11%, the alpha is +3 percentage points. Negative alpha means the…

9 cards
Study this deck

Alpha and Its Limits

In this lesson · 4 sections
Step 3 of 4

The Evidence

stacks of paper documents and file folders
Photo by Wesley Tingey on Unsplash

Mark Carhart's landmark 1997 paper in the Journal of Finance, "On Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance," studied US equity mutual fund returns over 31 years. After controlling for four systematic risk factors (market, size, value, and momentum), Carhart found almost no evidence of persistent positive alpha among fund managers beyond one year. The small persistence that existed in the short run was largely explained by momentum (good funds hold last year's winning stocks) and by the persistence of bad performance (consistently bad managers continue to underperform, partly due to high fees).

A large subsequent literature has confirmed this picture. The S&P SPIVA reports, published twice yearly, show that over ten-year periods, the majority of actively managed funds in most categories underperform their benchmark indices. The fraction that beat the index over ten years is consistent with what you would expect from chance alone, even before fees. After fees, the picture is bleaker still.