Fees and the Zero-Sum Game

Before costs, alpha is a zero-sum game: every dollar of outperformance by one investor corresponds to a dollar of underperformance by another. After costs, the average active investor must underperform the average passive investor by exactly the amount of fees and transaction costs. This is arithmetic, not a hypothesis: William Sharpe laid it out in his 1991 paper "The Arithmetic of Active Management."
The uncomfortable conclusion: genuine alpha exists but is rare, difficult to identify in advance, and largely consumed by the fees charged to access it. For most investors, attempting to identify skilled active managers is a negative expected value activity.