Samuelson's Counterargument
Paul Samuelson challenged the time diversification argument in a 1963 paper, "Risk and Uncertainty: A Fallacy of Large Numbers." His insight was that while the annualised standard deviation of returns decreases with time, the absolute dollar uncertainty in terminal wealth increases.
Consider a simple example. An investor with £100,000 invested for one year faces bounded terminal wealth uncertainty. Extend the horizon to 30 years. The annualised standard deviation is much lower, but the portfolio has grown to roughly £761,000 at the expected return. A small percentage standard deviation on a portfolio of that size produces a much larger absolute pound range of outcomes than the one-year case. The investor faces more total wealth uncertainty, not less.
Samuelson's point is that time diversification is a statistical artefact: it reduces annualised percentage variance while simultaneously increasing the absolute size of what is at risk.